Call us: (905) 936-3441

Our Family,
Protecting Yours.

Our Services

Home Insurance

Auto Insurance

Farm Insurance

Commercial Insurance

The Secret to Our Success:

A Great Team at McGoey Insurance

At McGoey Insurance, our success is built on a dedicated team. When issues arise, our local brokers prioritize your needs above all else. We represent you, managing claims and coverage on your behalf.

 
We’re like family—reach out to us to discover how we can offer the coverage you need.

Testimonials

“My wife and I have been dealing with McGoey Insurance for a number of years and have always had excellent service. We insure our houses, cars and motorcycle with them. We recently dealt with Nicole who went out of her way to make sure our information was correct and up to date. We couldn’t have asked for better service.”

Robert Matthews

Customer

“Extraordinary service. Great rates that reward loyalty. My whole family has been with them for decades. Nicole O’Callaghan is a superstar. Small town warmth. Big city smarts.”

Karen Howe

Customer

“I have recently had Nicole take over all my insurance needs and have been nothing but impressed. The attention to detail on my file has been second to non from Nicole. She goes above and beyond to make sure things are taken care of and in proper order. I have business insurance, home insurance, snowmobile insurance, and personal vehicle insurance that she has made very easy and orderly to keep track of. I 100% recommend getting in touch with her for all your insurance needs.”

Adam Lynch

Customer

Latest McGoey News

LOCAL SPONSORSHIP
We love to support our local teams! Check out the TNT Tornado’s U10A Team this season. Hockey has always been such an important part of our community, bringing families, friends,… Read more: LOCAL SPONSORSHIP
Alliston Readers Choice 2025 Nominees!
We’re proud to share some exciting news — McGoey Insurance Brokerage has been nominated in the Alliston Readers’ Choice Awards for Best Insurance Company! Even more exciting, two of our… Read more: Alliston Readers Choice 2025 Nominees!
Why is insurance getting so expensive?
If you’ve renewed your car or home insurance lately, you may have noticed the premium has jumped. That’s not just perception — 2025 is seeing continued upward pressure on insurance… Read more: Why is insurance getting so expensive?